A first line manager joins a briefing with their own manager and learns that another significant change is coming.
Costs need to reduce, performance needs to improve and some established ways of working will have to change.
They understand the broad direction and are given the key messages to take back to the team.
The difficulty starts when those messages meet operational reality.
Back with the team, the questions are more specific.
Why are we doing this now?
What happens to the targets we have already been given?
Has anyone considered the impact on customers?
Which piece of work takes priority if we cannot do everything?
The manager can answer some of those questions, but not all of them.
More importantly, they can already see practical problems that may not have been obvious when the decision was made.
Two priorities conflict. The timescale looks ambitious.
A change that makes sense strategically may be difficult to implement with the resources available.
This puts the first line manager in an important position.
They have a responsibility to represent the organisation and help their team understand the direction it is taking.
But they also have a responsibility to represent operational reality back into the organisation.
Doing one without the other reduces the role to little more than message delivery.
That relationship between senior leadership and first line management is easy to underestimate.
Senior leaders need managers who are confident enough to tell them what they need to know, not simply what they want to hear.
First line managers, on the other hand, need to know that raising a legitimate concern will be treated as useful leadership rather than resistance.
When that relationship works, information flows in both directions.
When it does not, senior leaders can become increasingly disconnected from what is actually happening while first line managers become increasingly skilled at absorbing the pressure.
And that can be costly.
Senior leaders understandably spend much of their time looking ahead.
They are thinking about strategy, budgets, customers, risk, investment and organisational priorities. They need a broad view of the business.
A first line manager sees something different.
They see where a new process actually slows the work down.
They hear the question a customer keeps asking.
They know which employee has quietly become the person everyone relies on and which member of the team appears to be coping but is beginning to struggle.
They know that two different departments have been given priorities that make perfect sense independently but conflict the moment somebody tries to deliver both.
Much of this information will eventually appear elsewhere.
Customer frustration might become a complaint. Excessive workload might become absence or turnover. A poorly designed process might eventually affect productivity data.
The first line manager often sees the problem before it becomes a number. That makes the management layer incredibly valuable.
Their role is not simply to take strategy downwards. They are also one of the organisation's most important routes for bringing reality upwards.
Yet that only works if managers believe they can speak honestly.
Imagine a senior manager asking how a change programme is progressing.
There is a substantial difference between the FLM saying, 'It's difficult, but we're getting there', and saying, 'The team understands what we're trying to achieve, but the new process is adding approximately 15 minutes to every case. We're starting to see a backlog, and I don't think the current target is achievable unless we change either the process or the resource.'
The second answer is more useful. It is also more difficult to give.
The manager has moved beyond reporting activity and offered a professional judgement.
They are not rejecting the change. They are giving senior leadership information that should improve its implementation.
Organisations need more of this, not less.
We often talk about confidence as though it is an individual characteristic.
Some people have it, others need to develop it, and a leadership course should somehow provide it.
The reality is more complicated.
A first line manager can learn how to communicate assertively, challenge constructively and present evidence.
But whether they continue using those skills will be heavily influenced by what happens when they do.
This is where psychological safety becomes particularly relevant.
Amy Edmondson's work on psychological safety is sometimes misunderstood as creating an environment where everybody is comfortable or where difficult messages are softened. It is much more useful than that.
Psychological safety describes an environment in which people believe they can take appropriate interpersonal risks, including raising concerns, questioning assumptions and admitting mistakes.
For senior leaders, that creates an important test.
It is easy to say, 'My door is always open.' The culture is revealed by what happens when somebody actually walks through it with information the leader doesn't particularly want to hear.
If an FLM raises a concern and immediately hears, 'We need solutions, not problems', they learn something.
If they challenge a timescale and are told that everybody simply needs to be more positive about the change, they learn something.
If they explain that their team is at capacity and the response is a comparison with another department apparently managing perfectly well, they learn something.
Eventually they may stop raising the issue.
That can create a dangerous illusion for senior leaders. The absence of challenge begins to look like the absence of problems.
Meanwhile, those problems have not disappeared. They are simply being managed locally, absorbed by teams or filtered out of the information travelling upwards.
Senior leaders therefore have a responsibility to become curious when challenged.
Instead of immediately defending the decision, they can ask what the manager is seeing, what evidence supports their concern and what they think needs to change.
That does not mean agreeing with every objection.
Senior leaders will have information that the FLM does not have, just as the FLM has operational information that senior leadership may not see.
Sometimes a difficult decision remains the right decision.
The important thing is that both perspectives can enter the conversation before that judgement is made.
There is another side to this.
It would be too easy to place all responsibility on senior leadership and argue that FLMs will speak honestly if only the culture is supportive enough.
First line managers are leaders too, and leadership sometimes requires saying something that would be easier not to say.
Confidence in this context does not mean certainty. Nor does it mean becoming confrontational. It means being able to offer a professional view even when the person receiving it has greater organisational authority.
The quality of that challenge matters.
'The team aren't happy' may be true, but it gives a senior leader very little to work with. What are people unhappy about? What has actually happened? What is the impact? Is the problem temporary discomfort associated with change, or evidence of something that genuinely needs reconsidering?
A more confident manager learns to separate observation from interpretation and bring useful evidence into the conversation.
The principles behind the SBI approach can be useful here.
By focusing on the situation, the observed behaviour or circumstances, and their impact, a manager can move away from generalised frustration and towards a conversation about something tangible.
A manager might explain that since a new approval process was introduced, customer queries requiring a particular decision have remained open for longer. Repeat calls have increased and members of the team are now spending additional time dealing with customers who believed their issue had already been resolved.
Rather than simply complaining about the new process, the manager can explain the operational consequence and offer a recommendation.
That is considerably more powerful than saying, 'This isn't working.'
It is also an important part of the transition into genuine management.
FLMs need to recognise that they have a voice because they have responsibilities that extend in both directions. They are responsible to the people they lead, but they are also responsible for contributing useful information to the organisation they manage within.
Sometimes that means respectfully challenging upwards.
One of the reasons this relationship can become difficult is that legitimate challenge and resistance to change can sound remarkably similar at first.
Both may begin with somebody saying, 'I don't think this is going to work.' The difference often becomes clearer through the conversation that follows.
Resistance may be driven primarily by a desire to preserve the familiar.
Constructive challenge normally develops as evidence, consequences and alternatives are explored.
A capable FLM should be able to explain what they are seeing and why it matters.
A capable senior leader should be willing to investigate before deciding which of the two they are hearing.
This requires maturity on both sides.
The FLM needs to avoid becoming the spokesperson for every complaint in the team. Management is not about passing dissatisfaction upwards unchanged. Sometimes the manager's job is to provide context, make the organisational case and help their people adapt.
Equally, the senior leader should resist the temptation to interpret challenge as a lack of commitment.
A manager can support the objective and question the method.
They can understand why a cost reduction is necessary while highlighting a customer consequence.
They can support organisational change while believing the proposed timescale creates unnecessary risk.
Being able to hold those two ideas at the same time is part of good leadership.
There is another reason FLMs sometimes struggle to lead with confidence: they have been given the decision without enough of the thinking behind it.
A manager who receives five bullet points to cascade to the team may be able to repeat them perfectly. The difficulty comes with the first question that isn't covered by the script.
People rarely want only the corporate message. They want to understand what it means for them.
Why this option rather than another?
What problem are we trying to solve?
Which parts are fixed and which can still be influenced?
What happens if something does not work as expected?
If the manager has not been given enough context, they have two choices.
They can admit they don't know, repeatedly, which eventually undermines confidence in their role.
Or they can fill in the gaps themselves, creating different explanations across the organisation.
Neither is particularly helpful.
Senior leaders can change this by giving managers enough context to exercise judgement rather than simply providing messages to repeat.
That means explaining the reasoning and trade-offs behind important decisions. It also means being clear about decision-making authority.
FLMs need to know where they have freedom to adapt and where there are genuine constraints.
A manager will struggle to lead confidently if they believe every decision they make might later be overturned by somebody more senior.
Autonomy without boundaries creates uncertainty. Boundaries without autonomy create dependency.
Clarifying both enables managers to lead.
Of course, some first line managers will still find upward challenge difficult.
That is hardly surprising. Many have been promoted because they were strong technical performers, reliable team members or experienced specialists. They may never previously have needed to challenge somebody two or three levels above them.
Simply telling them to 'be more confident' is unlikely to help.
Like most management capability, this can be developed through practice.
Managers can learn how to structure a difficult conversation, separate evidence from assumptions and make a recommendation rather than simply raising a problem.
They can practise disagreeing respectfully and learn how to remain composed when somebody questions their reasoning.
They can also learn that confidence doesn't require having every answer.
There is considerable credibility in being able to say, 'I may not have the complete picture, but this is the pattern I'm seeing,' or 'I understand why we're doing this, but I think we need to consider this consequence.'
Those are not signs of weak leadership.
They are signs of judgement.
Senior leaders can support this development through the conversations they have with FLMs.
Instead of solving every problem brought to them, they can ask the manager what they think is happening, what options they have considered and what they recommend.
Over time, the FLM learns that their judgement is expected, not merely their compliance.
This relationship is particularly important during periods of significant change.
Strategies are necessarily built at a level of abstraction. They describe where an organisation needs to go. Implementation exposes the detail.
It is at the front line that somebody discovers the new process takes longer than expected, two systems don't interact particularly well, customers react differently from the forecast or an apparently simple change requires employees to abandon a habit built over ten years.
None of this necessarily means the strategy is wrong.
It means the organisation is learning.
The speed at which that learning makes its way back to decision-makers can determine how quickly the organisation adapts.
That is why senior leaders should be interested in more than whether a change is 'on track'. They need to know what managers are noticing. Where are people finding the change difficult? What assumptions are being challenged? Which unintended consequences are beginning to emerge?
Equally, FLMs should resist the temptation to protect their teams by criticising senior leadership from a safe distance.
It is easy to tell a team, 'I agree with you, but this has come from above.'
It may preserve the manager's relationship with the team temporarily, but it also undermines their leadership.
A better response is more balanced.
The manager can acknowledge concerns, explain the organisational reason for the decision and take legitimate questions back through the appropriate channels.
That is what leading from the middle looks like.
It isn't blindly defending every organisational decision, and it isn't automatically siding with the team against 'management'.
It is being credible in both directions.
There is an important implication for leadership development here.
Organisations often invest in the first line manager and assume the surrounding leadership system will remain unchanged.
Managers attend programmes where they learn about feedback, delegation, coaching, emotional intelligence and difficult conversations.
They return enthusiastic about using what they have learned, only to discover that some of the behaviours encouraged in the training are not particularly welcome in the workplace.
We encourage managers to empower people, then require them to seek approval for relatively minor decisions.
We teach them to coach, then fill their diaries so completely that every conversation becomes transactional.
We tell them to speak up, then become defensive when what they say is inconvenient.
Under those conditions, the old behaviours usually win.
Developing confident first line managers therefore requires attention above the first line too.
Senior leaders and managers-of-managers need to understand how their own behaviour either creates or reduces capability beneath them.
If they want managers to exercise judgement, they must allow appropriate decisions to remain with them.
If they want challenge, they need to respond constructively when challenged.
If they want honesty, they need to be careful not to reward the managers who consistently provide the most reassuring version of reality.
This doesn't mean removing accountability. In fact, the opposite is true.
A manager with genuine authority can be held more meaningfully accountable for how they use it.
A manager who is expected merely to follow instructions will inevitably pass responsibility upwards when things go wrong.
The goal is not independence from the organisation. It is stronger leadership within it.
First line managers occupy one of the most commercially important positions in an organisation.
They influence how employees experience leadership, how quickly performance problems are addressed, how effectively change is implemented and how accurately information moves between the frontline and senior decision-makers.
Yet we sometimes treat their confidence as something they must develop alone.
It isn't.
First line managers need to develop the skills to communicate clearly, challenge constructively and lead through uncertainty.
They need the confidence to share what they are seeing and the judgement to distinguish between a genuine operational concern and the inevitable discomfort that sometimes accompanies change.
Senior leaders have an equally important responsibility.
They create the environment in which those behaviours either strengthen or disappear.
Their response to challenge teaches managers whether honesty is genuinely valued. The context they provide determines whether managers can explain decisions convincingly. The authority they delegate influences whether FLMs learn to make decisions or simply escalate them.
Get this relationship right and something important changes.
First line managers stop being a layer through which messages simply pass. They become a genuine part of the organisation's leadership capability.
They translate strategy into practical action while bringing operational reality back into strategic thinking.
They can stand in front of their teams and lead with confidence because they understand the direction, know where their authority begins and ends, and trust that they can raise legitimate concerns.
Senior leaders benefit too.
They receive better information, earlier warning of emerging problems and stronger management beneath them.
Perhaps that is the real measure of confidence in the middle.
It isn't having managers who confidently agree with everything.
It is having managers who know when to support, when to question and when to speak up, alongside senior leaders confident enough to listen.
The BCF Group has been helping organisations develop their people for over 25 years. Our first line management and leadership development programmes focus on the practical behaviours that managers need in the real world: communicating with clarity, influencing others, managing performance, coaching, handling difficult conversations and developing the confidence to exercise sound judgement.
Great first line management is not created by developing managers in isolation. It is strengthened when the organisation around them gives them the context, support and appropriate authority to put those skills into practice. Get in touch to learn more.